Andrew M. Hanna Explains Who Bears Responsibility When Repairs Fail in Properties Magazine
Frantz Ward Partner Andrew M. Hanna explains how owners, developers, lenders, property managers, and general contractors can manage defect risk long after renovation and restoration projects wrap up in his October Properties Magazine “Legal Perspectives” article, “When the Repair Becomes the Claim.”
Drew notes that defects in older buildings can surface months or years after the work is finished, when the original team has moved on and project records may be thin. The key questions are who remains responsible and whether the documentation supports a claim.
Ohio Deadlines, Narrow Warranties, and Renovation Risks
Drew outlines the two time limits that typically govern Ohio construction claims:
- Statute of limitations: Ohio generally allows six years to bring a claim on a written contract, though some contracts attempt to shorten that window
- Statute of repose: Ohio law generally bars many claims against those who worked on a property improvement once a decade has passed since substantial completion, even if the defect doesn’t come to light until later
He also explains why standard repair warranties often leave owners with a narrow remedy, and how renovation work adds risk through concealed conditions uncovered during demolition and multiple contractors working in the same area over time.
Addressing Risk Before Work Begins
He recommends that project teams:
- Spell out whether the contractor’s obligation covers only the individual fix or how the broader system performs
- Record the substantial completion date in closeout documents and the warranty file
- Decide whether a standard warranty is enough for long-life systems such as roofs, masonry, and waterproofing, and if not, negotiate longer coverage in a written extended warranty
- Set a rule that hidden substrate or earlier faulty work is not covered until the owner has been notified, shown photos, and decided how to proceed
- Avoid substituting commercial general liability insurance for a warranty
- On multi-phase projects, record the condition of existing work with photos, marked drawings, or memos before the next contractor starts
Drew also encourages buyers and lenders reviewing older properties to determine when major systems were last substantially finished, which firm did the work, whether any warranty is still in effect and can be transferred, and whether the same problem has happened before.
Read the full article here.
Drew’s practice consists of representing construction owners, managers, contractors, design professionals, and surety companies, among other construction professionals. He assists clients in all aspects of the commercial construction process from inception through completion.
Since 1946, Properties Magazine has been a monthly reporter on development, construction, design, and property management throughout Northeast Ohio.